P-01 · UAV Propulsion Testing Program
Small Brushless Motor Comparative Evaluation
Fourteen motors for sub-250 g, 3-inch FPV aircraft (twelve 1404-class, one 1504, one 1505), all tested on the same HQProp T3x3x3 propeller. The goal was to find useful performance balance, not just pick the motor with the highest advertised KV or peak thrust.
Method
- Measured KV: no-load RPM at 7 V, read optically. Measured values came in up to 10.4% below the advertised rating.
- Thrust sweep: 0–100% throttle at about 16 V, logging RPM, thrust, torque, voltage, current, and power.
- Efficiency: mechanical output (τω) divided by electrical input, compared at a common 50 W output.
- Torque: an inertial flywheel dynamometer spun from 5,000 to 20,000 RPM, with torque inferred from angular acceleration.
- Responsiveness: repeated 10→50→10% throttle steps, averaging acceleration and braking rates.
- Scoring: cohort-relative scores (100 = average), plus a weight-normalized score for mass-critical builds.
Key findings
- Advertised KV didn't predict loaded performance. Measured KV ranged from 2,915 to 4,428.
- The iFlight XING 1504 had the highest raw score (117.9), but its 11.2 g mass dropped it to 98.5 once weight was counted.
- The T-Motor F1404 4600KV was the best all-around motor: above average in every category and lighter than average.
| Priority | Motor | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Best all-around 1404 | T-Motor F1404 4600KV | 8.9 g · 408 gf · 70.4% · fastest response (176 kRPM/s) |
| Max raw performance | iFlight XING 1504 3900KV | 414 gf · 36.9 mN·m · 11.2 g |
| Long-range / cruise | Happymodel EX1404 3500KV | Lightest at 8.1 g · best efficiency at 73.4% |
| Balanced moderate KV | Skystars 1404 3800KV | Highest 1404 torque (32.8 mN·m) · 366 gf · 71.8% |







